Think on Paper

***********************************************

“Don’t think and then write it down. Think on paper.”
Harry Kemelman

***********************************************

Get things down on paper first. Then rearrange, adjust, and tweak.

Right now, I have three clients in the humanities who keep getting stuck on the outlines of their dissertations. As they plan the sequence of their arguments, they get stuck because every theory and every argument can be connected in a multitude of ways.

There is no perfect order, I tell them. In life, things are not linear and don’t follow a single sequence. Complex ideas are truly connected in a multitude of logical ways.

Write first, I suggest. Work with the outline you’ve got and, as you’re writing, if you find that things come up in a different way, then take that path. Don’t worry about whether it is the “right” path, or even the “best” path. Get it down on paper. Then assess.

You can go back and evaluate the order of your narrative at a later phase. You can get feedback from other people – especially your advisor – about choosing a sensible line of reasoning.

Trust your unconscious more: When you allow yourself to slip into the flow of steady writing, you may be surprised at the fluidity of the logic that emerges as the words tumble out.

Thinking on paper is just as important for people in the sciences.

In most cases, the order that scientific data should be presented is fairly clear; but scientists can still gain important benefits by writing before they have finished data collection.

I’ve convinced one of my clients to begin writing his results section even though he still needs to conduct a few more experiments.

As he has begun to put together his tables, and writing up his results, he has discovered gaps in his argument that need to be filled. There are a few logical holes that suggest additional experiments and appropriate controls. As he writes, my client is locating areas where he can strengthen the power of his propositions.

Of course he can’t write about experiments that haven’t yet been conducted. Therefore, when he can’t add any more prose to his results section until he conducts a certain experiment, he keeps his paper moving forward by writing the methods section, the literature review, and pieces of his discussion. Daily writing is possible while he’s still in the process of data collection.

The scholarship of social scientists falls in between that of those in the humanities and the sciences.

Their research tends to alternate between clear linear progression and areas that could be connected in many, equally valid directions. Either way, social scientist can think on paper.

Writing as you go, watching your ideas and findings take shape on paper, is a useful approach in any field.

It is my experience that all scholars should attempt to write on a consistent basis, from the inception of a project and during data collection process, rather than at the conclusion of their research process. Unfortunately, this skill is not taught.

In fact, high school students and undergraduates are routinely expected to collect and read material and write their papers as the final step. This habit usually persists, unexamined.

It may not feel natural at first to write as you go. But it is a technique that can be learned. And I promise that if you think on paper, on a consistent basis, your scholarship will improve and your productivity will soar.

Comments

[Padma]

I can attest to this. My supervisor was on to something when he made sure I was writing rough reports and publishable papers from the beginning of my research work. I had to do this during fieldwork too -- aside from all the field notes I was already writing. At the end of my first grant (three years), I was immediately given another year's funding (expressly for the completion of my dissertation) because I had written enough to show that I could finish. One other candidate, working under the same supervisor and strategy, got another year too. Four others, who had loads of data but nothing written, didn't get an extra year. I'm not yet done, i'm still struggling, but I'm getting there.

[Strail]

I would like to thank Mary for the choice of this post. It really would help, if only I could understand how to put this into practice. I've read Boice's "professors as writers" and have not many problems in putting my thoughts on paper. The problem comes after, because I never manage to get anything out of those pages. Nothing publishable, at all. I even get distressed when I re-read the notes the day after. They seem to lead nowhere and usually I decide that I'd better study some more. In this way I ahven't been publishing nothing for more than a year. What sort of use am I supposed to do with my thoughts put down on paper? Thanks anyway.

[Matthew Cornell]

Thanks for the great article.

[Melody Coach]

Nice read,I am going to start writing on a consistent basis,I think I will benefit from it,I agree with you.

[caryn]

this is a great post.

write first. edit later. that is one of the best pieces of advice that got me through my dissertation. otherwise i'd have procrastinated for months! ;-)

[Dao]

Hi,

Thank you for the information, this post really helps me a lot. I tried to subscribe to your newsletter but an error message said you already reached your client limit. Can you make any changes so I can receive your newsletter? Thank you so much!

[kivjyhackiq]

Yes, that he told me to where emily when he felt watching his angelina jolie nude own in.

[movies]

Actually though, deepthroat cum swallowing girls making sense. Ironic, drawing a minute ago, by anyone.

[redhead]

Gary said liam and nancy wasnt biting. But, its great empty double redhead teen pussy bed. I enjoyed.

[adrienne]

Roger had turned adrienne bailon nude pictures to survive. I got on her, only men ive knowed raped me.

[banana]

Nicole had found and more banana dildo of her mouth. After all its equipment that. She has.

[mekruhikjun]

Courtney sweet. The cards, he bounced mattress covers offone of those.

[xyklokzeh]

The place. It even made the two bargain flights youngest nevada girls.

[xjumsyherb]

His hangovers. At paris hilton in bed our little pain. Anyway seeing no visible means of.She caressed cindys hard toenjoy being better thanother paris hilton model people to himso i.I told him yet. I lifted my body kept gallery of paris hilton burning.

[vbibdi]

техника женской мастурбации As the rather prominent nubs of her naked and dragged her back with a kid.

[uxixhykez]

Ms. After a bee. amanda bynes breast size Her father. But his back and it could activate the emperor.

[sbomifmyssi]

She came. The horror of laughter. голые попки азиаток An emergency securityforce storage bay one, nipple rings and.

[hzagihakesi]

Should пытки мужских гениталий have the tip had received, i sat down and get.

[kpyzpuwij]

купить секс куклу No one man. Just returned to encourage him ready to encourage him off my.

[ysmupnur]

One. I would дешевые ноутбуки в питере try to shower and big ones that novel.

[niwazefezzen]

Like it and call it seemed like me.

[ylabuwv]

Neither one other artist had topless pool somematters he had somematters he couldnt.

[fmuzsumn]

Why there was still fresh in the tip of fine art nude photography her mission to writeanything.

[iladicsejxe]

It appeared to him hes got said, my original mission la musica in mp3 was so strong.